United Colors of Benetton Controversial Advertising Campaign

United colorise of Benetton controversial Advertising CampaignMOHAMED RAFIQUE BIN RAMLANThe United modify of Benetton Controversial Advertising CampaignsAn Analysis on Power of Determining the Meaning of Media schoolbookbook editionThe need to effectively sell to consumers byout many cultures across domain of a function borders compelled businesses to tailor their advertising strategies to appeal to different geographic markets. The United change of Benetton however, has been employing the opposite strategy by trying to impart a single, what the stain perceived to be universally accepted message that would generate confirmatory responses from all consumers regard slight of their geographical, sociological, psychological, cultural, and economical make-up. Ironically, historically speaking, the defects runnels, which had a reputation of being controversial despite claimed as an labor to invoke universally positive take accounts have consistently sparked prejudicial res ponses from their audiences (Boches, 2011). The movement for this disconnection between the expected results and true(a) outcomes is that the campaigns render perceivably negative images so explicitly that they ended up misleading the audiences away from the stains well- mean centre.According to Hall, the app arent gist (how the importation is ultimately perceived by the audience, regard little whether it aligned with the intended meaning) of a media text is not alone inherent in the text itself nor the institution responsible for its production. It varies according to the interpretations of its audiences. It passing correlates with and dependent on the audiences cultural scope, economic standing and personal experiences, and everything else the audiences had already identified and acknowledged (Hall, 1973). Hall added that the audiences are capable and often do distort the messages themselves through collective action, whether consciously or subconsciously. Thus, the aud iences effectively became lively participants in decode media texts messages as they impose their own social scene in their interpretations. Thus, the thesis of this essay is that the ability to determine the meaning of a media text lies primarily with the audience. This essay analyzes collar of the blots campaigns, focusing on the system cover of audiences perceptions on each campaign, which can be categorised into three different piazzas as proposed by Stuart Halls seat of converse theory.In 1980s, acclaimed photographer Olivero Toscani captured the image for the greases notorious campaign, which the note claimed to be an effort to raise awareness on social issues pertaining to rush and effectively parent the value of racial integration (Elliot, 1991). The scrape ad for the campaign portrayed a depiction of a (apparently Caucasian) white climb girl innocently posing side-by-side with a (apparently of African ethnicity) black scramble girl. At face value, this mo ve ad seemed to be just some other print ad promoting multi-racial value. With closer inspection, the print advert added to the negative design of black people in the media. The black struggle girl appeared to be somewhat dark and grimy. There is no representation of happiness in the look in her face. The eyes giving the expression of emotionless and bleak with her insipid stare, half of her appearance hidden by dark shadows with no make a face on her face and hair styled with spikes which somewhat resembles a pit of tiny horns. This connotation of obscurity is reflected to the arbitrary meaning with malicious in society. In addition, somewhat societies claimed the looks appeared to be somewhat devilish because they associated darkness with negative appearance. (Moore, 1991) However, the white skinned girl quite apparently enhanced with digital editing appeared to look happy and healthy. Her blond curly haired and a smile underneath her rosy cheeks brands her to look innocence and radiant in person. This resembles her to be styled and edited to look somewhat angelic with her cupid-like look. (Moore, 1991)Especially in the U.S., the forwarding of racial integration value from this particular print ad was less apparent in comparison to the sensational outburst manufactured by this print ad by apparently reinforcing negative stereotypes on black skinned people. whizz might argue that portraying obviously negative stereotypes undermines against them quite a than reinforces them, yet tense racial dynamics in the United States resulted in dominantly negative perception towards the meaning of the print ad.The intended meaning of the print lies at which Hall established as the negotiated position, where the meaning is in a position that compels the audience to both accept and reject the intended meaning. The portrayal of the black skinned girl as explicitly and by artificial means devilish proved to be counter-productive to the intention of the print ad to promote the values of embracing other cultures and ethnicities. To a certain extent, the audience do recognized and acknowledged the intended meaning, but simultaneously resisted and modified the meaning in a way which reflects their own experiences, interests, and biases (Hall, 1980). Hall stated that decoding within the negotiated version contains a mixture of adaptive and oppositional elements while the audiences someway recognized the abstract idea behind what they were perceiving, the formation of meaning in their minds operated at a to a greater extent restricted, situational condition, establishing new rules which ultimately shaped the meaning of the media text.In the 1990s, the controversy ignited by the brands take aback campaign intensified. The brands shift in focus towards more gritty social issues ranging from dying AIDS patient to image of blood-smeared garment (Mezzofiore, 2011) faced not only negative reaction from audiences, but sparked human beings protests an d banned by many governments across the world. The print ad which depicted the blood-smeared clothes of a dead Croatian soldier was intended as a part of a campaign that promotes anti-war effort (Associated Press, 1994). One dividing line which could justify the explicitly gory depiction of the print ad is that it makes for an ardent emotional appeal to the consumer, evoking feeling of compassion in them and to perceive the brand as sympathetic and with conscience, ultimately increasing brand appeal and loyalty. Ironically, the German court ruled that the print ad could not be build anywhere in the country on ground that using much(prenominal) intense emotional appeal to sell product is immoral (Walsh, 1995). many audiences perceived the image as too disturbing to reflect the value of peace the brand claimed to promote and they could not make any advised connection between print ad and the product the brand is very selling.In this case, the intended meaning of the campaign w as within the oppositional position when channelled through a medium ready to be perceived by its audiences. One of the prevailing philosophy of the brands advertising strategy was that there are no shocking pictures, only shocking reality which reflected the brands effort to expose realities that people refuse to see and face. The brands campaign strategy relied on the assumption that the value that it is promoting through this campaign is universally positive, and that it is immune to any interpretations (whether or not they are misleading) formed by the audiences on the basis of their overall make-up. In this oppositional position, the audiences unsounded only the literal meaning of the image and blinded themselves from the intended meaning. The audience decoded the message and formed interpretation in a way the campaign did not foresee. The audiences sociological make-up has placed the meaning in the oppositional position as to what the meaning was supposed to be. Although som e may actually agnize the intended meaning, the text of the medium did not speak in the alike(p) language as the audiences, thus they ended up rejecting it. (Hall, 1980)After consistently recorded low sales, presumably due to a string of high-profile withal unpopular ad campaigns (Maguire, 2003), the brand finally employed a drastically different advertising strategy with its Unemployee of the year campaign in 2012 that communicate the issue of youth unemployment. The campaign was also a contest in which unemployed youths could win EUR 5,000 that they would use to implement a project that would create a positive impact on their community (Lidbury, 2012). The campaign have a series of thematically focused print ads which depicted close-ups of youths diametrical with captions such as Valentina, 30, non-lawyer from Italy. The brand campaign presents a realistic portraying of todays society by actively tackling a current problem, that of youth non-employment and the dominance con flict between generations, in order to show it in a new light and create value for the immense human great(p) of young people. This time, the campaign generated more positive responses in comparison to the previously mentioned campaigns which were perceived as exploitations of social issues that do not attempt to create solutions.In this case, the audiences were located within the dominant point of view where the audiences took the actual meaning of the media text directly and decoded it exactly the way it was encoded. The audience fully dual-lane the text codes and successfully reproduced the texts intended meaning (Hall, 1980). Since the issues of youth unemployment are arguably universal, misunderstanding during version media text did not occur as both the sender and receiver have the corresponding cultural biases. The sharp turn of strategy made by the brand was evident by disapproval that the print ads for the campaign are too boring (Mahdawi, 2012) and did not represent what they have recognized the brand for controversy. However, this criticism was overwhelmed by the overall positive response towards the brands effort to provide solutions to youths unemployment. Marketers predicted that the campaign would help the brand build a unrelenting human relationship with its target consumers.The Reception Theory which focuses on the readers reception of a literary text or media established that the process of negotiation and opposition of meaning take place when the reader is interpreting the text. A text- be it a book, film, or other creative take form are interpreted by their respective audiences who are not behaving passively, but acting as active participants in interpreting the meanings of the text (Morley, 2015) found on their individual make-up. In other words, the meaning of a media text is not inherent within the text itself, but is created within the relationship between the media text and the audience. A correct interpretation of the meani ng of a specific text could only occur when the audiences have a shared cultural background and interpreted the text the way the producer of the text presumed it would be interpreted. The less shared heritage an audience has with the producer of the media text, the less likely the audience will be able to recognize the producers intended meaning. Two audiences with vastly different cultural, sociological, economical, psychological, and geographical background will extract two very different meanings from the same text. Thus, the power to determine the meaning of a media text lies primarily with the audience.References (Word Count 1638)1. (Fabrica) http//www.seouldesign.or.kr/EBOOK_DATA/pdf/fabrica_seminar.pdf2. Boches, E. (2011) terzetto Ways to Look at Benetton The Cause, The Creative, The Controversy, Creativity Unbound. Online operable at http//edwardboches.com/three-ways-to-look-at-benetton-the-cause-the-creative-the-controversy. (Accessed celestial latitude seventeenth 2014 )3. Gianatasio, D. (2011) Benetton is Not Feeling the Love for its Unhate Kissing Campaign pontiff Ad is Quickly Pulled, Adweek. Online Available at http//www.adweek.com/adfreak/benetton-not-feeling-love-its-unhate-kissing-campaign-136587. (Accessed declination seventeenth 2014)4. Crawshaw, S. (1995) Benetton Sued everywhere Shock Ads, The Independent. Online Available at http//www.independent.co.uk/news/world/benetton-sued-over-shock-ads-1569139.html. (Accessed December 17th 2014)5. Walsh, M. W. (1995) German Court Bans Shocking Benetton Ads Law Panel Labels as iniquitous the Clothiers Campaigns on HIV, Oil Slicks and Child Laborers, Los nonsuches Times. Online Available at http//articles.latimes.com/1995-07-07/news/mn-21071_1_benetton-ads. (Accessed December 17th 2014)6. Moore, L. W. (1991) Is Ad Theme Racial Harmony or Angel/Devil Stereotype?, Philly.com. Online Available at http//articles.philly.com/1991-09-12/news/25799573_1_benetton-campaign-racial-harmony-oliviero-toscan i. (Accessed December 17th 2014)7. Elliot, S. (1991) The Media Business Advertising Benetton Stirs more Controversy, The New York Times. Online Available at http//www.nytimes.com/1991/07/23/business/the-media-business-advertising-benetton-stirs-more-controversy.html. (Accessed December 17th 2014)8. Mezzofiore, G. (2011) Benetton A History of Shocking Ad Campaign, International Business Times. Online Available at http//www.ibtimes.co.uk/benetton-history-shocking-ad-campaigns-pictures-252087. (Accessed December 17th 2014)9. Kenna, A. (2011) Benetton A Must-Haves becomes a Has-Been, Bloomberg Business Week Magazine. Online Available at http//www.businessweek.com/magazine/ content/11_12/b4220021488483.htm. (Accessed December 17th 2014)10. Hall, Stuart (1980) Encoding/decoding. In Centre for Contemporary ethnical Studies (Ed.) Culture, Media, Language. London Hutchinson.11. Schrder, Kim Christian. (2000). Making sense of audience discourses Towards a multidimensional model of mass media reception. European Journal of Cultural Studies, 323312. Salkeld, Richard , 2014. rendering Photographs An Introduction to the Theory and Meaning of Images. 1st ed. London Bloomsbury Publishing. pp64-6513. Benetton Group Website. Online Available at http//www.benettongroup.com. (Accessed January eleventh 2015)14. Maguire, M. (2003) United Colors of Benetton A Company Of Colors And Controversies. GRIN Verlag.15. A campaign to combat the culture of hate, unhate.benetton.com16. Mahdawi, A. (2012), Benettons Unemployee of the Year is a Flimsy Attempt at Brand-Aid, The Guardian, Online. Available at http//www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/ family line/19/benetton-unemployee-campaign-flimsiest-brand-aid. (Accessed January 11th 2015).17. Lidbury, O. (2012) Benetton Launch Unemployee of the Year Campaign, Fashion. Online Avalable at http//origin-fashion.telegraph.co.uk/columns/olivia-bergin/TMG9552570/Benetton-launch-Unemployee-of-the-Year-campaign.html. (Accessed January 11th 2015).1 8. AP News Archive (1994). Latest Benetton Poster Provokes Croat Outrage With Am-Yugoslavia. Online Available at http//www.apnewsarchive.com/1994/Latest-Benetton-Poster-Provokes-Croat-Outrage-With-AM-Yugoslavia/id-83dd11f663e4b97caf2026954d083f9d. Accessed 11 January 15.19. Morley, D. (2015) Audience Research, Museum Of Broadcast Communications Online Available at http//www.museum.tv/eotv/audiencerese.htm. Accessed 11 January 15.20. Hall, S. (1973) Encoding/Decoding Culture, Media, Language Working Papers in Cultural Studies, 1972-79, pp. 128-138.